Skip to Content

Caribbean Mule: The Dark And Stormy Cocktail

Rum Moscow Mule, Dark and Stormy, Caribbean Mule, Spiced Rum Moscow Mule. It doesn’t matter what you call this delicious and refreshing drink, it is one of the best cocktails out there! If you are looking for something easy to make and popular with almost everyone, you can’t go wrong with this riff on the classic Moscow Mule. 

Dark and Stormy Rum Cocktail with Lime and Ginger Beer

This post contains affiliate links. Please read my Disclosure for more information. 

More Mule Cocktails

Apple Cider Moscow Mule

12 Fall Vodka Cocktails

 What Is A Dark and Stormy?

The Caribbean mule is a cocktail made with rum, ginger beer and lime. It’s a refreshing drink that is simple to make and is perfect for sipping on a hot summer’s day. 

How did the Caribbean Mule come to be?

Basically someone wondered “Can you substitute rum for vodka in a Moscow Mule?” and the answer was a resounding yes! 

In fact the Dark and Stormy is the National drink of Bermuda and was created there. 

Of course, some people think that the Dark and Stormy was invented during the pirate era when many ships were filled with rum. During one stormy night, they combined some of their leftover ingredients with rum and the Caribbean Mule was invented! 

It doesn’t matter how this drink was created, the truth is, a rum Moscow mule is a delicious variation of the classic New York cocktail. 

Dark and Stormy Rum Cocktail with Lime and Ginger Beer

What is in a Caribbean mule?

If you are familiar with the classic Moscow Mule then the ingredients of the Dark and Stormy will be very familiar. You simply switch out the vodka for rum in the Caribbean Mule. I used both spiced rum and dark rum in my Dark and Stormy.
 
Some versions also use simple syrup but that is mainly personal preference. If you like your cocktails a bit sweeter then you can add some. 
 

Dark and Stormy Ingredients

  •  Spiced Rum
  • Dark Rum
  • Ginger Beer
  • Lime juice

What Kind Of Rum Do Your Use In A Caribbean Mule? 

Dark rum is the rum of choice in a Dark and Stormy which is how it got the name! I used Captain Morgan dark rum and Captain Morgan spiced rum too but you can use any kind you like. 

The Dark and Stormy originated in Bermuda so the traditional rum to use is Goslings Black Seal Rum. 

How To Make A Dark and Stormy

  1. Add the rum and lime juice to a glass with ice
  2. Top with ginger beer
  3. Add a slice of fresh lime for garnish

Spiced Rum Moscow Mule – FAQS

Caribbean Mule

Can you use white rum in Moscow Mule?

Yes, if you are more of an aficionado of white rum rather than spiced rum, you can absolutely use it instead of the dark rum.  Your drink will still be a Caribbean Mule but maybe not quite as “dark” and stormy as a drink made with dark rum.

What is the difference between a Moscow Mule and a Dark and Stormy?

There are two mani difference between the Moscow Mule and a Dark and Stormy. 

First, a Dark and Stormy contains dark rum and/or spiced rum instead of Vodka (which is the liquor in a Moscow Mule). 

Secondly, a Moscow Mule is traditionally served in a served in a copper mug while a Dark and Stormy is served in a high ball glass. 

What Is A Moscow Mule With Rum Called?

A Moscow Mule made with rum is normally called a Caribbean Mule or a Dark and Stormy if you use dark rum. 

Dark and Stormy Rum Cocktail with Lime and Ginger Beer
Yield: 1

Dark And Stormy Cocktail

Prep Time: 3 minutes
Cook Time: 1 minute
Total Time: 4 minutes

If you love rum cocktails then this Caribbean Mule is the perfect drink for you! This island- inspired twist on the classic Moscow Mule cocktail is easy to make and delicious.

Ingredients

  • 2 oz Spiced Rum
  • 2 oz Dark Rum
  • 5 oz Ginger Beer
  • 1 Lime Wedge
  • Ice

Instructions

  1. Add your rum and ginger beer to your glass over ice
  2. Squeeze the lime wedge over the drink and then add the lime to your drink
  3. Stir the drink and garnish if you like.

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Instagram

More Fun Mule Cocktails

Blueberry Moscow Mule

The Ultimate Champagne Moscow Mule

Apple Pie Moscow Mule (Plus Apple Pie Mocktail)

dark and stormy cocktail

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Skip to Recipe